What are the warning signs that money is going missing, and what should we do?
Most irregularities are mistakes. A few are not. The aim is to notice early, stay fair, and follow a process, not to guess at causes.
Short answer: Notice the signs, write down facts rather than guesses, tell a second officer, and follow your own process, which may include the board chair or your adviser. Do not accuse anyone, confront anyone alone, or change records to hide a gap.
This is not tax, legal or accounting advice. It describes common practice. Where a rule depends on law, ask your adviser, and follow your own organization’s rules and your bank’s requirements.
The steps
Know the signs
Common signs include reconciliations that are late or never done, deposits that are delayed or differ from the count, missing receipts, one person doing everything, records that are not shared, reluctance to take a break or hand over, and bank statements that do not arrive for review.
Remember that mistakes are far more common
Copying errors, timing differences and lost paper explain most problems. Begin by assuming a mistake, and check the facts.
Write down what you see
Record dates, amounts, documents and who told you what. Stick to facts. Do not write guesses about people.
Do not confront anyone alone
Do not question the person involved on your own, and do not discuss it with others. A calm, private word with the board chair or another officer is the first step.
Tell a second officer
Report what you found to the board chair, another officer, or whoever your rules name. If the chair is involved, use the next person in your rules.
Follow your own process
Check your bylaws or policies for what to do. If there is none, the board decides together. Ask your adviser what to do next, including whether anyone outside the organization needs to be told.
Preserve the records
Keep the originals as they are. Do not mark, fix or throw away anything. Make copies to work from.
Check the facts carefully
Have someone who is not involved review the bank statements, count sheets and deposits for the period. They compare them with the records.
Stay fair
Everyone is treated as innocent until facts say otherwise. Keep the circle of people who know small, and keep the matter private.
Learn from it
Whatever the cause, use the occasion to improve routines. See the list below.
Habits that make problems easier to spot
- Two people count, and both sign.
- Someone who does not handle cash reviews the bank statement each month.
- Deposits are made promptly and match the count sheet.
- Payments are approved by a second person.
- The treasurer takes a break now and then, and someone else does the routine.
- Records are kept in a place the organization controls.
Related guides: monthly bank reconciliation and when the count does not match the deposit.
What this page is not
We cannot tell you whether a situation is a legal matter, what you must report, or what your duties are. Those answers depend on law and your own rules. Ask your adviser early.
Speaking up as a volunteer
If you are not the treasurer and something worries you, you do not need proof. Say what you noticed, as a question, to the chair or another officer. A good board welcomes questions and does not treat them as accusations. Everyone who handles money in an organization benefits from clear routines that anyone can check.
Questions people ask
What if I am not sure whether it is a problem?
Write down the facts and ask a second officer to look with you. Asking a question is not an accusation.
Should we tell the police straight away?
That is a decision for your board and your adviser, based on the facts and the law. Do not decide alone.
What if the person involved is the treasurer?
Report to the chair or the next officer in your rules. A treasurer who is asked for records should be able to provide them calmly. Follow your own process and keep it fair.
Free printable
Open the ten practices for small-organization money, ready to print on US Letter paper. No email needed.