VThe Vera Standard

How do we keep members' giving private from other volunteers?

What a family gives is personal. A few simple habits mean that only the people who must see it do.

Short answer: Decide who needs to see giving records and why, keep as few people as possible, store the records in a locked place or a protected file, share totals and not names with boards and committees, and write down the rule. Ask your adviser about any legal duty that applies.

This is not tax, legal or accounting advice. It describes common practice. Where a rule depends on law, ask your adviser, and follow your own organization’s rules and your bank’s requirements.

The steps

  1. Decide who really needs to know

    Usually the treasurer, a records person and perhaps the pastor in limited cases. Everyone else works from totals.

  2. Write the rule

    A half-page policy: who may see individual giving, for what purpose, and that it is not discussed outside that group. The board approves it.

  3. Separate duties where you can

    The people who count the offering need names only to record gifts. The people who set budgets need totals. Keep the roles apart. See separation of duties.

  4. Use numbers on the count sheet

    If your church uses envelope numbers, counters can record numbers and a records person links them to names later.

  5. Store paper records safely

    Keep giving records in a locked cabinet. Do not leave count sheets or envelopes on a desk.

  6. Protect the computer file

    Use a password, and share the file only with those who need it. See passwords and access for the treasurer's files.

  7. Report totals to the board

    Board and committee reports show totals by fund, not by person. See the monthly report.

  8. Brief your volunteers

    Remind counters and records volunteers each year that giving is private, and that it is never discussed in the hallway.

  9. Handle questions kindly

    When someone asks what another member gave, say that your church keeps giving private, and offer to help them with their own record.

  10. Share statements only with the giver

    Giving statements go to each giver, by hand or by post. Do not leave a pile unattended. See getting the records ready for statements.

  11. Dispose of old records carefully

    When your adviser says records may go, shred them. Do not throw giving lists in a bin.

Pastors and leaders

Some churches choose not to let the pastor see individual giving, so that care and teaching are not influenced by amounts. Others allow limited access. Your board decides and writes it down. There is no single right answer.

If privacy is breached

If a list is lost or shared by mistake, tell the chair, find out what happened and what was shared, and ask your adviser what to do. Tell the people affected honestly. Then fix the habit that caused it.

What this page does not do

We do not give legal advice about privacy duties. These depend on your location and your organization. Ask your adviser.

A one-paragraph policy you can adapt

“Individual giving records are private. Only the treasurer and the records volunteer may see them, and only for the work of recording gifts and preparing statements. Boards and committees receive totals by fund. Giving is never discussed outside this group. Records are kept in a locked place or a protected file.” Adapt the words to your church, have the board approve them, and give a copy to each volunteer who handles records. A short, clear rule that is read once a year does more than a long one that nobody remembers.

Questions people ask

How do we keep members' giving private from other volunteers?

Limit who sees individual records, use totals for boards and committees, store records safely and write down the rule.

Should the pastor see who gave what?

Churches differ. Your board decides and records the rule.

What do we say if someone asks what another person gave?

That your church keeps giving private, and offer to help them with their own record.

Related guides