How do we keep contractor records ready for 1099 season?
Most of the January rush is finding forms and adding up payments. A list kept through the year turns it into an hour’s work.
Short answer: Keep one list of everyone you pay for work who is not on payroll, ask each for Form W-9 before the first payment, record every payment with its date, amount and how it was paid, and total each payee at year end. Which payees need a form, and when, is set by the IRS: check the current IRS instructions or ask your adviser.
This is not tax, legal or accounting advice. It is a way to keep records in order. The rules on these forms come from the IRS; read the current instructions or ask your adviser, and follow your own organization’s rules.
The checklist
Make one payee list
List every person or business the organization pays for work who is not on payroll: the musician, the cleaner, the DJ for the school dance, the bookkeeper, the website helper. Use one name per payee and spell it the same way every time.
Ask for the form before the first payment
Many organizations ask each new payee for IRS Form W-9 before paying them for the first time. It is much easier to ask at the start than in January. Note the date it came back on the payee list.
Keep the forms private
A W-9 holds a tax number. Keep the forms in a locked place or a protected folder, not in email or on a volunteer’s home computer. See passwords and access for the treasurer’s files.
Get an invoice or a short agreement
For each job, keep the invoice, or a short note of what was agreed, the price and the dates. File it with the payment.
Approve and pay in a traceable way
Follow your normal approval rule and pay by check or bank transfer. See paying bills on time. Avoid paying for work from cash takings.
Record how each payment was made
Write down whether you paid by check, bank transfer, card or a payment app. The IRS instructions treat some payment methods differently, so your adviser will want to know.
Keep reimbursements apart
Paying a volunteer back for supplies is not the same entry as paying someone for work. Record volunteer reimbursements under their own heading, so each payee’s total is clean. Ask your adviser about any mixed case.
Check the list each quarter
Every three months, compare the payee list with the bank statements. Add anyone who was paid but is missing, and chase any form not yet returned.
Total by payee at year end
After the last statement of the year, add up the payments to each payee, split by how they were paid. Put the totals on one page and have a second officer check them against the bank.
Check the current rules
Which payees need a form, which form, the amount and the deadlines are set by the IRS and can change. Read the current IRS Instructions for Forms 1099-MISC and 1099-NEC, or give your one-page totals to your adviser.
Record who files and when
Note who prepared any forms, the date they were filed or sent, and where the copies are kept. Put the copies in the year’s folder. See keeping the treasurer’s records.
An example
Example payee list (made-up names and figures)
| Payee | Work | W-9 on file | Paid by | Year total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A. Rivera Music | Sunday organist | Yes, 8 Jan | Check | $2,400 |
| Bright Clean LLC | Hall cleaning | Yes, 2 Feb | Bank transfer | $1,950 |
| J. Okafor | Website fixes | Asked 14 Mar and 2 Apr | Payment app | $300 |
The third row is the one to chase now, not in January. Whether any of these payees needs a form is for the IRS instructions and your adviser.
Where the rules are
The official sources are the IRS pages for Form W-9 and the current Instructions for Forms 1099-MISC and 1099-NEC, on irs.gov. Check them each year rather than relying on last year’s notes, and write the year’s figures and dates in your file. If your organization has an accountant or a volunteer adviser, give them the one-page totals early.
Questions people ask
What amount means a payee needs a form?
The IRS sets that, and the figure has changed in recent years, so we do not print one here. Check the current IRS instructions or ask your adviser, and write the figure for the year in your file.
Who decides whether someone is a contractor or an employee?
Not the treasurer alone. It depends on IRS rules about how the work is done. If you are unsure about anyone you pay, ask your adviser before the next payment.
What if a payee does not return the form?
Do not fill in details yourself. Note each date you asked, tell the officer who approves payments, and ask your adviser what to do before you pay again.
Where do we keep the forms?
In a locked place or a protected folder the organization controls. They hold tax numbers, so only the treasurer and one other officer should open them.
Free printable
Open the ten practices for small-organization money, ready to print on US Letter paper. No email needed.