VThe Vera Standard

What do we do with checks made out to the wrong name?

It happens often: a check arrives made out to the pastor, the treasurer, an old name of the organization, or a misspelling. Here is a calm way to handle it.

Short answer: Do not alter the check. Note what is wrong, ask your bank what it will accept, and if it cannot be deposited, return it politely to the giver and ask for a new one. Record what you did. What a bank accepts is the bank's decision; ask your bank and your adviser.

This is not tax, legal or accounting advice. It describes common practice. Where a rule depends on law, ask your adviser, and follow your own organization’s rules and your bank’s requirements.

The steps

  1. Stop and look

    Read the payee line and the memo. Note exactly what it says, who it is from and the amount.

  2. Do not change the check

    Do not write over, cross out or add a name on the front of the check. Do not sign it on behalf of someone else.

  3. Write down what you have

    On the count sheet, note the check number, the giver, the amount and what is unusual. Both counters initial the note.

  4. Keep the check safe

    Put it aside in the locked deposit bag or safe, apart from checks that are ready to deposit.

  5. Ask your bank what it will accept

    Banks have their own rules for checks made out to a person, a similar name or an old name. Call or visit and ask, in plain words, what they need.

  6. If it was made out to a person

    A check payable to an individual may need that person's endorsement and the bank's agreement. Ask the person to speak to the bank, and ask your adviser if there is any doubt.

  7. If the name is old or misspelled

    Some banks will accept a small variation if the organization's account is the same. Others will not. Ask the bank before you try.

  8. If it cannot be deposited

    Return it to the giver with a short, friendly note, thank them for the gift and ask for a replacement. Record that you returned it and when.

  9. Tell the giver kindly

    People are often embarrassed. Say that a small correction will make sure the gift reaches the right account.

  10. Record the replacement

    When the new check arrives, count it as usual. The gift is recorded when it is deposited, with the date and the giver.

  11. Prevent it next time

    Put the organization's exact legal name on giving envelopes, the website and the giving instructions. Mention it in the bulletin or newsletter.

Keeping a record

Keep a short log of unusual checks: date, giver, amount, issue, what you did, and who agreed. A second person reviews the log each month. It protects you, and it helps the next treasurer. Related: how to count the Sunday offering.

What this page does not do

We do not give legal advice, and we cannot say what any bank will accept. Banks differ, and rules differ by place. Ask your bank and ask your adviser.

Tell the finance chair

If you have an unusual check, tell the finance chair or another officer the same week. A second person who knows protects you if the giver later asks a question.

Mailed checks

Checks that arrive by post should be opened by two people, listed on a sheet, and added to the next deposit. If a check is odd, follow the same steps.

A short script for the giver

“Thank you so much for your gift. Our bank needs the check to be made out to our exact name, so we are returning it with the correct name written below. Could you send a replacement? We are grateful for your generosity.” Keep it warm and short, and keep a copy for your records. Most givers are glad to fix it.

Questions people ask

Can we cross out the wrong name and write ours?

No. Do not alter a check. Ask your bank what it will accept, or return it to the giver.

Should we deposit it and see what happens?

It is better to ask the bank first. A returned item can cause fees and confusion.

What if the giver has moved or cannot be reached?

Keep the check safe, record what you tried, and ask your bank and adviser what to do. Tell the finance chair.

Free printable

Open the free offering count sheet, ready to print on US Letter paper. No email needed.

Related guides